Skip over navigation

Instructions: To enter the debate, choose your side below, and post your argument. You may vote for the top argument below by clicking the Vote Up button. You cannot vote for your own argument.
Edit: You have 10 minutes to make any changes. Click to edit
Who is the better running back?



Choose a Side:
1 Eric Dickerson Why?
2 Walter Payton
Arguments Posted (9)
  • Sort by:
 
Posted by anaya01 | 3 months ago
Vote Up (0)

Walter Payton was the ultimate back w/ all the tools, great hands,good blocker and can also throw the ball. Rarely injured and can take a hit. Sweetness was the greatest.

My Side: Walter Payton
report abuse | reply |
 
Posted by OKLAKID | 1 year ago
Vote Up (0)

Defence strategies have devopled better since Walters days. Eric was in tougher times.

My Side: Eric Dickerson Why?
report abuse | reply |
 
Posted by KillerBuzz | 1 year ago
Vote Up (0)

All the moves

My Side: Walter Payton
report abuse | reply |
 
Posted by StevieB82 | 1 year ago
Vote Up (0)

Sweetness had all of the tools - strength, speed, shiftinesss, great hands and he could block. He was the ultimate team guy even though he was the team's best player. Dickerson, while a great ballcarrier, did not have all of Walter's tools.

My Side: Walter Payton
report abuse | reply |
 
Posted by mgoblu | 1 year ago
Vote Up (0)

he was a very hard runner.

My Side: Walter Payton
report abuse | reply |
 
Posted by thechief | 1 year ago
Vote Up (0)

Dckerson was a better rusher

My Side: Eric Dickerson Why?
report abuse | reply |
 
Posted by tollx26 | 1 year ago
Vote Up (0)

Stronger runner...better receiver and blocker. Didnt like to run outta bounds,,would rather take a tackler head-on!! One of the top 5 of all-time!!

My Side: Walter Payton
report abuse | reply |
 
Posted by thenater | 1 year ago
Vote Up (0)

Payton was a better overall back.

My Side: Walter Payton
report abuse | reply |
 
Posted by Duranimal | 1 year ago
Vote Up (0)

Who has to most yards.

My Side: Walter Payton
report abuse | reply |
  • Votes: 0
  • Arguments: 9
  • Tags: Sports
  • Short URL:
Post a Comment (View Guidelines)
Add Image|Add Video
Comments (0)

Find Debates
Start Debate
More Debates
 
Debates
Your City: PHOENIX, AZ (change)


MakeYourTake - Sports Pick'em - Arizona Sports - azcentral.com